Active or Passive? Its a walk-over!

TV-Bay Magazine
Read ezine online
With the forthcoming Olympics being broadcast in 3D free-to-air, there is sure to be a surge in new TV purchases. Given so many 3D capable models to choose from, which is best?
Until the manufacturers come out with autostereoscopic designs that work properly in high definition, we have to view 3D though some sort of glasses to separate the left and right images when viewing a 3D TV set. For home entertainment, there are only two main choices: active or passive glasses.

Active 3D glasses use an electronically sequenced shutter to alternately blink each eye in synchronism with the display showing left and right images in quick succession. This is possible because plasma and modern LCD panels are capable of very fast switching so can create left and right images within the timespan of a single television frame.
It costs the manufacturer little more to make a 3D-ready set than a 2D model with 100/120 Hz refresh. The down side is that the active glasses are expensive because they need two high-speed LCD shutters, the associated drive electronics and some kind of wireless receiver for the sync signal, plus a battery. They are also relatively bulky.
With passive 3D glasses system, the extra cost arises in the LCD panel manufacture. (This technology is not suitable for plasma panels). In a 3D LCD, the screen polariser has a layer of alternating strips of left and right handed filters that are accurately line-up with the display line structure. Viewed in 2D with no glasses, this makes no difference to the viewer. Passive 3D glasses have low-cost left and right hand polarisers that filter out the images which are vertically separated by the TV’s display filters. So here the set is more costly and specialised to make but the glasses cost almost nothing compared with the £50 to £100 per pair charged for active types.
This is why new 3D active sets come with one or two pairs in the box. With passive glasses, you might get 10! But technically which is best? Active shutter systems give the full vertical resolution and you do have a choice of plasma as well as LCD technologies. However, modern LCDs are just as good as plasma and the loss of vertical resolution with passive glasses is not really apparent in normal viewing conditions. Motion portrayal can be noticeably better with passive glasses. Then there is question of brightness. With both systems each eye is only seeing roughly half image and through a light reducing filter. So both are about the same or slightly less for shuttered. Some people report that flicker is annoyingly visible with active glasses.
When you add in the cost of three or more spare sets of active glasses to the price of the set, an active model is more expensive. If you want the cheapest initial purchase, if you have no friends or family, if you are never going to lose or break your active glasses, if you don't mind the batteries going flat, and if you are not going to take them round to a friend's house and expect them to work there too, then go for an active system.
However if you want to share the 3D viewing experience with visitors and not worry if they walk off with or sit on your £1 glasses, then go for a passive 3D TV set. Perhaps LG.

Robin Palmer is Managing Director of Cel-Soft and is currently involved with software solutions for 3D & TV quality control and measurement technology.

Tags: iss061 | 3d glasses | active 3d glasses | passive 3d glasses | N/A
Contributing Author N/A

Read this article in the tv-bay digital magazine
Article Copyright tv-bay limited. All trademarks recognised.
Reproduction of the content strictly prohibited without written consent.

Perimeter LED screens management
Nicolas Houel Opened in January 2016, Parc Olympique Lyonnais, also known as Groupama Stadium, is the new home of Olympique Lyonnais football club, one of the most popular clubs in France. Since its inauguration, the stadium was a host of UEFA Euro 2016, and was also chosen to stage, among other important events, the 2018 UEFA Europa League Final and football at the 2024 Summer Olympics.
Tags: iss133 | 3dstorm | graphics | groupama stadium | liveexpert | livecg | deltacast | Nicolas Houel
Contributing Author Nicolas Houel Click to read or download PDF
Why are trade shows still important
Mike Crimp First, the disclaimer: as the CEO of a rather large trade show, my opinion is likely to be skewed. However, I wouldn’t be here – now in my eighth year at IBC - if I didn’t truly believe that well-curated trade shows like IBC are a hugely important resource for our industry.
Tags: iss133 | ibc | innovation award | Mike Crimp
Contributing Author Mike Crimp Click to read or download PDF
Taking on a self employed placement year
Joshua Round The idea of being self-employed or freelancing has always been somewhat terrifying for me. There is a level of uncertainty and responsibility that comes with the freedom of being self-employed, the likes of which makes me wonder why I chose to give it a go for my placement year as part of my university course - (BSc) Television and Broadcasting.
Tags: iss133 | placement year | university | student | education | portsmouth | Joshua Round
Contributing Author Joshua Round Click to read or download PDF
Creating Authentic Content That Counts
Frank le Mair We’re deep into the 2010’s and the way in which we consume content has changed forever. Broadcasters and content owners are fighting for eyeballs in a saturated market where consumers are watching their favourite shows on different devices across a number of platforms. To target millennials and younger generations, who generally consume short bursts of video on YouTube and social media - particularly Snapchat, Instagram and now IGTV - media companies are creating more and more authentic stories and are using platforms that are compelling for this demographic. Unlike generations before them, they have totally new video viewing patterns and ideals.
Tags: iss133 | insight tv | monster energy | amazon | millennial | Frank le Mair
Contributing Author Frank le Mair Click to read or download PDF
How todays technology platforms can make AMAZING seem mundane
Bruce Devlin - new Some things never change. It's September and it's time for another IBC. Maybe I'm getting old and maybe I have selective memory about the past, but recently there hasn't been the buzz of years gone by. Sure, as you wander around the vast halls there will be lots of enthusiastic sales people trying to give you the best demo possible, but something has changed and to survive, I believe that vendors and customers need to change too.
Tags: iss133 | ibc | class | vulture | imf user group | Bruce Devlin - new
Contributing Author Bruce Devlin - new Click to read or download PDF