The New ITU-R BS1770-2 Loudness Standard


History
The ITU-R standard BS1770-1, released in 2006, describes a fundamental loudness measurement algorithm. The basic technique was validated through listening tests on varied program material, performed in labs around the world.
In late 2010 the ITU committee which maintains BS1770 accepted (after much negotiation) changes submitted by the EBU. The result is a significant improvement in the calculation of loudness, making it much more sensitive to the loud portions of an audio segment. The effect is to prevent advertisers from significantly increasing the loudness of a portion of a commercial by manipulating the loudness elsewhere, for example where an announcer screams at widely spaced intervals throughout a commercial in an effort to get the viewers’ attention: Though the average loudness might be reasonable, the peak loudness could be quite annoying. The new method puts more emphasis on the louder portions and assesses this spot as louder than the original method would have.
This new version of BS1770 has just been published, and meters in use will need to conform to the revised specification. Most meter manufacturers have been following the developments in the EBU and ITU and have upgraded their software accordingly. Unfortunately they may not have done it correctly, or else the update might not have been installed in the meter you are using.
The Problem
As a user, how do you assess whether a meter you are considering meets the revised specification? If it’s one you already have, how do you know if it has been modified to conform to the new requirements? We will describe a suite of tests developed specifically to check every aspect of a meter’s design and to give diagnostic information about any implementation issues that exist.
Our test suite comprises signals whose parameters change dynamically so as to stress individual portions of the measurement in isolation. Each test can then maximize its sensitivity to the specific implementation errors it was designed to detect. The signals were developed using mathematical models of the algorithm, including various intentional implementation errors, and were optimized to give the largest difference between readings obtained by correct and incorrect implementations.
The new BS1770 algorithm operates on a free-running 100ms measurement interval, so readings differ slightly with variations between the start of this interval and the start of the signal. Consequently the results for some tests are given as a range of acceptable values.
Understanding the ITU standard
The original BS1770-1 loudness measurement algorithm is diagrammed in Figure 1. The audio channels (except the LFE) are independently filtered with a low frequency roll-off to simulate the sensitivity of the human ear, and a high frequency shelf to simulate head diffraction effects. The combined response of these filters is referred to as “K weighting” and is illustrated in Figure 2. Surround channels are given a 1.5 dB boost to account for the relative gain provided by their position on each side of the listener. The individual channel powers are summed to obtain the surround program’s total power. This is averaged over the entire program yielding a single reading for the program loudness. If a “dynamic” indication of loudness is desired, a 3 second moving average is typically used. Readings are reported in LKFS (Loudness, K-weighted, relative to Full Scale) which may be thought of as “loudness dBFS”.
The BS1770-2 revision maintains the same filtering and power measurement, but changes the way measurements are averaged and presented. The integrator stage of Figure 1 is replaced with the processing shown in Figure 3. The power is summed over 400 ms intervals. These intervals overlap by 75% so a new value is obtained every 100ms. Results are gated with a Start/Stop control to allow selection of the audio segment to be measured. An absolute gate of -70 LKFS is applied, which eliminates lead-in and playout portions of isolated audio segments.
The algorithm focuses on the foreground portion of the audio by a two step averaging procedure (the yellow elements in Figure 3): The 400 ms measurement values are averaged over the content being measured. The resulting LKFS value is decreased by 10 and used to gate the 400 ms values a second time. The values which pass the second gate are averaged to form the final reading called “Integrated” loudness. This “relative gate” focuses the assessment on foreground sounds, which generally dominate viewers’ judgments of program loudness.
Loudness Meter Evaluation
The test suite described here is available for testing BS1770-2 compliance of any loudness meter. It may be downloaded as a dScope III script and supporting files from www.prismsound.com, or as a series of wave files and documentation from www.qualisaudio.com. More complete documentation of the tests and their expected results are included in the download package. Any new tests will be added as they are developed.
The menu for the script-based implementation is shown in Figure 4. The suite currently consists of 16 tests. All tests except Test 2 are stereo signals and should be applied to the LF and RF channels of a surround loudness meter. All tests except the first three comprise a 1 kHz sinewave at varying amplitudes. When the expected result is a range rather than a specific target, this is due to the 100ms alignment uncertainty.
The ITU BS1770 standard also describes a true-peak meter, which is checked by Test 1 as described in the technical note accompanying the test suite.
Test 2 is Dolby Digital encoded and stimulates all channels simultaneously, including the LFE. Power summation is checked by using sinewaves of slightly different frequencies. A compliant meter reads -23 LKFS. If the meter incorrectly sums in the time-domain, the reading will cycle. If the meter is affected by the LFE, the reading will be too high.
Test 3 checks the filter response at six frequencies: 25, 100, 500, 1 k, 2 k and 10 kHz using sinewaves of varying amplitudes to give a constant reading of -23 LKFS.
Test 4 alternates between -69.5 and -90 dBFS to exercise the absolute gating function. A compliant meter reads -69.5 LKFS. A meter which does not implement absolute gating reads -71.5 to -72.7.
Test 5 steps the amplitude between -23 and -6 dBFS at intervals between 0.5 and 1.4 seconds. A meter which correctly implements relative gating reads -7.7 to -8.2 LKFS; a non-compliant meter reads between -13.2 and -13.5.
Test 6 checks aspects of relative gating missed in test 5 by alternating between -36 and -20 dBFS. A compliant meter reads between -22.0 and -22.5 LKFS, whereas non-compliant meters read between -24.3 and -24.7.
Tests 10 through 15 evaluate an EBU-developed measurement called Loudness Range (LRA) which has not yet been accepted by the ITU. For more information refer to the technical note available with the test suite.
Test 16 measures the meter’s relative gate threshold, displaying -8 or -10 as appropriate. This is useful to determine if your meter is designed around the old standard and needs updating.
If a loudness meter gives the expected results for all of the tests, there is a very high likelihood that the implementation is compliant with BS1770-2.
Richard Cabot is the CTO of Qualis Audio and was previously CTO of Audio Precision. He was Chairman of the AES digital audio measurement committee for the development of the AES-17 standard. Ian Dennis is Technical Director of Prism Sound and as Vice-Chair of the AES digital audio measurements committee wrote the document which became the true-peak meter specification in BS1770.

Tags: iss054 | itu-r | bs1170 | ebu | calm | loudness | prism sound | dscope | N/A
Contributing Author N/A

Read this article in the tv-bay digital magazine
Article Copyright tv-bay limited. All trademarks recognised.
Reproduction of the content strictly prohibited without written consent.

Related Interviews
  • NUGEN Audio: Loudness Toolkit at NAB 2013

    NUGEN Audio: Loudness Toolkit at NAB 2013

  • Nugen Audio at NAB 2014

    Nugen Audio at NAB 2014

  • TSL Products SAM1 MADI at BVE 2014

    TSL Products SAM1 MADI at BVE 2014

  • Triveni Digital at NAB 2012

    Triveni Digital at NAB 2012

  • Junger Audio at IBC2011

    Junger Audio at IBC2011

  • JVC at BVE 2013

    JVC at BVE 2013

  • Emotion Systems at NAB 2012

    Emotion Systems at NAB 2012

  • DK-Technologies at NAB 2012

    DK-Technologies at NAB 2012

  • Nugen Audio Loudness Meter, Halo Upmix and Halo Downmix at NAB 2018

    Nugen Audio Loudness Meter, Halo Upmix and Halo Downmix at NAB 2018

  • Nugen Audio Loudness Toolkit at BVE 2016

    Nugen Audio Loudness Toolkit at BVE 2016

  • NUGEN Loudness Toolkit at NAB 2015

    NUGEN Loudness Toolkit at NAB 2015

  • The Telos Alliance at IBC 2016

    The Telos Alliance at IBC 2016

  • Wohler at IBC 2016

    Wohler at IBC 2016

  • NUGEN Audio at IBC 2015

    NUGEN Audio at IBC 2015

  • NUGEN Audio at BVE 2015

    NUGEN Audio at BVE 2015

  • RTW at IBC 2014

    RTW at IBC 2014

  • RTW at NAB 2014

    RTW at NAB 2014

  • Cobalt Digital at NAB 2014

    Cobalt Digital at NAB 2014

  • RTW at IBC 2013

    RTW at IBC 2013

  • NuGen Audio at IBC 2013

    NuGen Audio at IBC 2013

  • TSL Products at NAB 2013

    TSL Products at NAB 2013

  • TSL Systems at BVE 2013

    TSL Systems at BVE 2013

  • TSL Products at BVE 2013

    TSL Products at BVE 2013

  • RTW at NAB 2012

    RTW at NAB 2012

  • Qualis at NAB 2012

    Qualis at NAB 2012

  • TSL at BVE 2012

    TSL at BVE 2012

  • Sonifex at BVE 2012

    Sonifex at BVE 2012

  • Emotion Systems at BVE 2012

    Emotion Systems at BVE 2012

  • HHB and TC Electronic at BVE North2011

    HHB and TC Electronic at BVE North2011

  • Volicon at IBC2011

    Volicon at IBC2011

  • TC Electronic at IBC2011

    TC Electronic at IBC2011

  • Cobalt Digital at IBC2011

    Cobalt Digital at IBC2011

  • RTW at IBC2011

    RTW at IBC2011

  • DK Technology at IBC2011

    DK Technology at IBC2011

  • Linear Acoustic at IBC2011

    Linear Acoustic at IBC2011


Related Shows
  • Show 18 - April 24th 2013

    Show 18 - April 24th 2013


Articles
Sony HDC-4800 Review
Andy McKenzie First announced at NAB 2016, the Sony HDC-4800 is a studio camera system capable of shooting 4K/UHD at up to 8x or full HD at up to 16x. With a price point upwards of £250,000 it is a very high-end product with a wide feature set. In Sony's own words, "This is the future of live production, designed to satisfy the storytelling aspect of modern sports production.” Deliveries began in mid 2017 and, after careful preliminary evaluation, we invested in several systems for our hire fleet ahead of the FIFA World Cup in Russia.
Tags: iss134 | review | hdc-4800 | sony | finepoint | Andy McKenzie
Contributing Author Andy McKenzie Click to read or download PDF
What content providers need to know about OTT
Hiren Hindocha As OTT (Over-The-Top) technology has gotten more mature and established robust standards over the years, the concept of OTT monitoring is gaining popularity. With customer expectations soaring, it’s vital for OTT providers to deliver superior quality content. To deliver Quality of Experience (QoE) on par with linear TV broadcast, the entire system, starting from ingest to multi-bitrate encoding to delivery to CDN must be monitored continuously.
Tags: iss134 | ott monitoring | qos | logging | compliance | dash | atsc | cloud | Hiren Hindocha
Contributing Author Hiren Hindocha Click to read or download PDF
Protecting the continuity of transmission
Lorna Garrett Your viewers love you. You consistently bring them their preferred channels 24/7. They’ve come to rely on you for their viewing pleasure. They never miss cheering on their beloved sports teams. They’re the envy of their friends as they watch live concerts of their favourite bands. They gather the family around and catch up on their must-see shows. They don’t have a bad word to say about you.
Tags: iss134 | garland | gpl | streaming | artel | disaster recovery | Lorna Garrett
Contributing Author Lorna Garrett Click to read or download PDF
Shedding Light on the Blackmagic Pocket Cinema Camera 4k BMCPP4K
Garth de Bruno Austin “What is it about light that has us craving it?” Is the question asked in the opening seconds of Garth de Bruno Austin’s latest short, The Colour of Light. Exploring this natural, human need as well as our innate desire to control it, Garth’s film showcases everyday people going about their lives in differing degrees of luminance, whether that be an artificial streetlight or a natural morning sunrise.
Tags: iss134 | blackmagic | cinema camera | 4k | cpp4k | Garth de Bruno Austin
Contributing Author Garth de Bruno Austin Click to read or download PDF
The brave new world of software based production
Boromy Ung In today’s rapidly evolving broadcast industry, the only constant media organizations can truly count on is change — and the need to adapt as rapidly and cost-effectively as possible. One of the biggest agents of change is the IP revolution, driving broadcasters to migrate their operations to all-software solutions running on commodity, IT-based technologies.
Tags: iss134 | chyronhego | graphics | sports | ott | Boromy Ung
Contributing Author Boromy Ung Click to read or download PDF