VR and the importance of tracking


TV-Bay Magazine
Read ezine online
Download PDF
Download PDF

I would like to begin this article by clarifying what we at Shotoku mean when we talk about VR in live production. It’s not the production of immersive, 360 content where you need to wear a headset; we are talking about virtual studio (VS) and augmented reality (AR) work, such as placing graphics into a green screen environment or physical set. The technology used for this work is entirely different, though equally specialist – therefore it is important to understand the challenges of this kind of production in order to make informed kit choices.

One of the most important aspects of VR/AR production is accuracy, i.e. ensuring that the graphics are stable in the correct position relative to the set. If the tracking is not sufficiently accurate or starts to lose calibration, the graphics will start to drift and become unstable.

There are three main types of tracking system available today:

  • Mechanical tracking systems (encoder technology attached to or built into camera support equipment) capture vital camera positional information such as pan/tilt, height, X,Y floor position and zoom/focus parameters. This information is merged at the SPI (Serial Position Interface) box and feeds in real time via industry standard protocol to the graphics engine. At Shotoku we have built physical position tracking encoders into most of our products – including tripod heads, pedestals, cranes and robotics, providing a very wide choice of solutions.
  • Absolute external reference systems like Shotoku’s Free-d2 consist of a small upward-facing tracking camera mounted on the main camera, looking at a set of reference markers mounted to the studio ceiling or within the lighting grid. Lens data is combined with the video image and presented to the Free-d² processor which precisely calculates the camera’s 3D position and provides industry standard, frame-synchronized tracking data to any graphics engine.
  • Point of contrast referencing systems uses sensors attached to a camera to track features in the environment, thus providing positional information. The system needs to be able to see enough fixed points of contrast to maintain its tracking.

Some systems are more suitable for certain types of projects. If you are planning a live VR production, here are some factors to consider that might influence your choice of tracking technology.

1. Studio-based or outside broadcast?

Mechanical encoders and absolute systems both work well in a studio, but the latter are generally not flexible enough for location work. Instead you could use a point of contrast system; however, these systems can have difficulty performing under any change in lighting (e.g. the sun’s position changes, the sky clouds up, darkness falls during the production) making such systems less stable.

2. Green screen or hard set environment?

Systems that use sensors to track features in the environment rely on points of contrast; they can struggle in a green screen environment and may need to look away from the set to find their reference. A mechanical system may work better for a green screen production.

3. Cost vs Number of AR/VR channels

Mechanical encoding has the same cost per camera to be tracked. External tracking becomes more cost effective with multiple channels as a single installation of external targets will track multiple cameras. Obviously each camera needs a spotter camera but this is only part of the system cost.

4. Do you want to go handheld?

As encoders are embedded in the camera supports, mechanical systems are not suitable if you want to go handheld. Absolute systems take their references from the spotter camera and target tracking points, so as long as the spotter camera can see the markers, the main camera can be tracked regardless of how the camera is supported.

5. Moving between locations?

Absolute systems are by nature fixed installations and cannot be moved to another location. Mechanical equipment with built-in encoders can be moved around and set up as required.

6. Re-calibration requirements?

Mechanical systems by their very nature build errors over time, particularly if using pedestals prone to wheel slip on floors that are less than perfectly flat. When this happens the system needs to be recalibrated, which isn’t always easy on a live production. Speed is the key here, and Shotoku’s SPi-Touch two point calibration is one of the quickest systems around – it allows the operator to recalibrate in under a minute, quick enough to fit within a commercial break. Absolute systems very rarely drift as they do not have a mechanical interface, so they seldom need recalibration.

7. Tracking delay

Mechanical tracking systems output positional data in real time. Tracking delays must be considered, especially in cases such as lip-synching during a live event.

To choose a tracking solution that will cover most, if not all, of your requirements, talk to a tracking system manufacturer – preferably one that offers multiple types of system so they can be flexible in their advice. Tracking is a critical component in any VS/AR system so it pays to choose the right solution.


Tags: iss130 | shotoku | vr | live production | KitPlus
Contributing Author KitPlus

Read this article in the tv-bay digital magazine
Download PDF
Article Copyright tv-bay limited. All trademarks recognised.
Reproduction of the content strictly prohibited without written consent.

Related Interviews
  • Sennheiser VR at IBC 2016

    Sennheiser VR at IBC 2016

  • Elemental Technologies VR at NAB 2016

    Elemental Technologies VR at NAB 2016

  • Virtual and Augmented Reality support with the Arrow Fx7 from Miller at NAB 2017

    Virtual and Augmented Reality support with the Arrow Fx7 from Miller at NAB 2017

  • Ross Video at BVE 2017

    Ross Video at BVE 2017

  • Live Production with ChyronHego at NAB 2018

    Live Production with ChyronHego at NAB 2018

  • NewTek at IBC 2015

    NewTek at IBC 2015

  • Grass Valley at BVE 2015

    Grass Valley at BVE 2015

  • NewTek TalkShow at IBC 2014

    NewTek TalkShow at IBC 2014

  • PacTV Truck at NAB 2014

    PacTV Truck at NAB 2014

  • Grass Valley at BVE 2014

    Grass Valley at BVE 2014

  • Cobham: Mini RF Transmitters at NAB 2013

    Cobham: Mini RF Transmitters at NAB 2013

  • Cobham: RF Transmitter at NAB 2013

    Cobham: RF Transmitter at NAB 2013


Related Shows
  • Live production with Newtek at BVE 2015

    Live production with Newtek at BVE 2015


Articles
Creating Authentic Content That Counts
Frank le Mair We’re deep into the 2010’s and the way in which we consume content has changed forever. Broadcasters and content owners are fighting for eyeballs in a saturated market where consumers are watching their favourite shows on different devices across a number of platforms. To target millennials and younger generations, who generally consume short bursts of video on YouTube and social media - particularly Snapchat, Instagram and now IGTV - media companies are creating more and more authentic stories and are using platforms that are compelling for this demographic. Unlike generations before them, they have totally new video viewing patterns and ideals.
Tags: iss133 | insight tv | monster energy | amazon | millennial | Frank le Mair
Contributing Author Frank le Mair Click to read or download PDF
Managing Technological Change
Alan Wheable Continual technological change in the broadcast and media industries can make it difficult to plan for the mid to long term. Typically, broadcasters and media organisation are still implementing the last set of changes to working practices when the next changes come along.
Tags: iss133 | omnitek | ip | waveform | vectorscope | ultra tq | Alan Wheable
Contributing Author Alan Wheable Click to read or download PDF
Smashing the WTA Tour
Danny Ridler The Women’s Tennis Association (WTA) is the global leader in women’s professional sport with more than 2500 players representing nearly 100 nations competing for a record $146 million in prize money. The 2018 WTA competitive season includes 54 events and four Grand Slams in 30 countries. In 2017, the WTA was watched around the world by a total TV audience of 500 million – with host broadcast services provided by NEP UK.
Tags: iss133 | tennis | wta | nep | outside broadcast | ob | Danny Ridler
Contributing Author Danny Ridler Click to read or download PDF
Perimeter LED screens management
Nicolas Houel Opened in January 2016, Parc Olympique Lyonnais, also known as Groupama Stadium, is the new home of Olympique Lyonnais football club, one of the most popular clubs in France. Since its inauguration, the stadium was a host of UEFA Euro 2016, and was also chosen to stage, among other important events, the 2018 UEFA Europa League Final and football at the 2024 Summer Olympics.
Tags: iss133 | 3dstorm | graphics | groupama stadium | liveexpert | livecg | deltacast | Nicolas Houel
Contributing Author Nicolas Houel Click to read or download PDF
Fast-moving productions need multi-cam RF reliability
Darren Bilton Wireless acquisition creates a level of freedom not possible with any other form of filming yet only a decade ago the technique was barely possible. The technology enabling live real-time connections over radio frequencies has advanced leaps and bounds such that there is barely an entertainment, documentary, sports or news format today that doesn’t benefit from at least one link system. That means the demands on the kit continues to rise and includes the need for fail safe multi-camera operation, ease of use and backwards compatibility all within a small, lightweight and budget-friendly package.
Tags: iss133 | boxx tv | wireless | mpeg-4 | multicam | rf | multi-cam | Darren Bilton
Contributing Author Darren Bilton Click to read or download PDF