Fast 3D


Bob Pank#
It is easy to make the assumption that 3D should comply with existing standards, as in the 2D video streams of television or movie images running at 24, 25 or 30 frames per second, according to the relevant 2D standards. However, the recent step up to doubled frame rates, generally referred to as 50p or 60p for television and 48p (or higher) for movies, has shown significant improvements for the clarity of the images. After all, this is why much of the new television infrastructure is ‘3G capable’ to handle up to 1080/60p uncompressed video.
At the recent Kino Expo held in St. Petersburg, Nevafilm, supported by Doremi Cinema, RealD and Christie Digital, organized a presentation of 3D shown at 24, 48 and 60 fps – a first for Russia. A specially shot high frame-rate 3D movie was provided by Lightstorm with the assistance of Jon Landau, the producer of Avatar and Titanic. He pointed out that traditional film’s 24 fps was chosen as, “The minimum rate needed for smooth film motion and cost-efficiency for studios.” He also pointed out that film is an expensive recording medium and using double the frames per second would be significantly more expensive. Presumably it would double the cost of release prints which can be of the order of £1000 for a 2D feature in the UK. Of course, such costs would also restrict the use of 3D on film – a constraint that is removed with digital cinema.
He continued “But we live in a digital era now, where cinemas utilize small hard discs or electronic downloads instead of bulky film reels. So there is no obstacle to move to 60 fps. Moreover, cameras are ready for shooting at such rates. All you need is to update the software of the Series II digital projectors, already installed in the majority of cinemas, and use cinema servers able to support high frame rates.”
Of course the audience was very impressed with the results, as have been the many others that have seen it already in other countries. As the way 3D viewing systems operate means that frames are sequenced between left and right eyes, so tending to make them more prone to flicker, higher frame rates should significantly improve the audience experience. With most of the technology for fast frame rate movie production and exhibition in place it begins to look like a good idea and worth the effort to produce a better 3D experience for the audience.
Broadcast television has to clear more hurdles to achieve 3D 1080/50 or 60 in the home. Although the capability may already exist to shoot, edit and finish in the format, transmission would require double the bandwidth and no set-top box is designed to work this way. However most of the more modern panel screens can run at least as fast as 50 or 60 Hz. Maybe some brilliant compression system will help to make fast 3D TV a practical reality for terrestrial broadcast in the near future. Satellite has more bandwidth available.
To date 3D TV and film have been run on existing 2D standards and, as Landau points out, we could start using ‘fast 3D’ for movies now without much affect on cost over 24 fps 3D. The improvements that the St Petersburg audience appreciated echo those of others so maybe this will become commonplace one day. Of course there are benefits of ‘fast 2D’ also as the 24 fps imposes significant restrictions on the presentation of action such as sports and camera movement.
It is often pointed out that the biggest protagonists of 3D are the TV set makers. However the world’s biggest set maker, Samsung, does not support the professional equipment market – unlike Panasonic and Sony. Perhaps the most expected news of the last of the last few weeks was the announcement that much of the 2012 Olympics coverage will be available in 3D. Panasonic, the International Olympic Committee and Olympic Broadcasting Services announced their partnership agreement to make the London 2012 Olympic Games the first ever live 3D Olympic Games. This will “allow audiences around the globe to witness the world’s greatest sporting event in immersive 3D”. We are promised over 200 hours of coverage including the Opening and Closing ceremonies, athletics, gymnastics, diving and swimming, that will be produced and delivered to participating rights-holding broadcasters around the world. OBS will be in charge of production “by utilizing Panasonic’s state-of-art 3D production technologies including the AG-3DP1, a P2HD professional fully-integrated twin-lens Full HD 3D camera recorder”.
That brings me to Sony who is doing an excellent job of informing and training production personnel. Not only does it run courses but also its recent live web interview ‘Turning a 3D vision into OB reality’, staged at Wimbledon, chiming with the very successful 3D coverage there in the summer, was a very useful update of where live 3D is now. Sony’s Mark Grinyer chaired the informal session with Duncan Humphreys from Can Communicate and Peter Angell from HBS. Duncan when asked about what was new/ significant at IBC made the Panasonic connection. He saw the arrival of twin-lens 3D cameras from Panasonic (probably with an eye on the new AG-3DP1) and Sony as adding the ability to offer “run around and grabbing flash interviews” – a break away from the rigidity of the big complex 3D rigs. He also liked the compactness of the new Sony SRW data recorder saying it could record four 3D cameras in the space of one standard SRW unit. Peter Angell had noted that there were more, cheaper good 3D rigs which would help towards achieving the much needed increase in content production.
Scanning the news I note that EBU Director General Ingrid Deltenre delivered a keynote speech at the recent prestigious Prix Italia award ceremony, in Turin, where she questioned the possibility of 3DTV ever becoming the standard viewing format. Ms Deltenre is quoted as saying that “3DTV will be a valuable tool for broadcasters, and an enjoyable feature of some programmes. But it will be an optional complement to conventional broadcasting – not the standard format.” Although this reflects 3D Diaries’ view, indeed she may be a reader, it is disappointing that such an eminent industry figure feels unable to allow for any possibility of future significant technical developments or changes of viewing habits. While we agree with her statement as a reflection of the status quo, we never say never – especially in the rapidly developing area of 3D technology.

Tags: 3d | 3dtv | 3d diaries | iss058 | Bob Pank#
Contributing Author Bob Pank#

Read this article in the tv-bay digital magazine
Article Copyright tv-bay limited. All trademarks recognised.
Reproduction of the content strictly prohibited without written consent.

Related Interviews
  • 3D Storm show the new NDI to HDMI decoder at NAB 2019

    3D Storm show the new NDI to HDMI decoder at NAB 2019

  • 3D Storm presents LiveXpert and NewTek products at IBC 2018

    3D Storm presents LiveXpert and NewTek products at IBC 2018

  • 3D Storm discuss IP and NDI for Live Media Server and Live CG Broadcast at NAB 2018

    3D Storm discuss IP and NDI for Live Media Server and Live CG Broadcast at NAB 2018

  • LiveCG Broadcast and LiveMedia Server from 3D Storm at BVE 2018

    LiveCG Broadcast and LiveMedia Server from 3D Storm at BVE 2018

  • NDI and Newtek Products from 3D Storm at IBC 2017

    NDI and Newtek Products from 3D Storm at IBC 2017

  • LiveMedia Server and Live Xpert from 3D Storm at NAB 2017

    LiveMedia Server and Live Xpert from 3D Storm at NAB 2017

  • 3D Storm with LiveXpert at BVE 2017

    3D Storm with LiveXpert at BVE 2017

  • 3D Storm at IBC 2016

    3D Storm at IBC 2016

  • 3D Storm at BVE 2016

    3D Storm at BVE 2016

  • 3D Storm at IBC 2015

    3D Storm at IBC 2015

  • Brainstorm Multimedia: Aston3D at NAB 2013

    Brainstorm Multimedia: Aston3D at NAB 2013

  • Brainstorm Multimedia at IBC 2015

    Brainstorm Multimedia at IBC 2015

  • BRAINSTORM VIRTUAL SETS at NAB 2015

    BRAINSTORM VIRTUAL SETS at NAB 2015

  • Brainstorm Multimedia at BVE 2015

    Brainstorm Multimedia at BVE 2015

  • Brainstorm on BroadcastShow LIVE at IBC 2013

    Brainstorm on BroadcastShow LIVE at IBC 2013

  • Brainstorm with Aston demonstration at IBC 2013

    Brainstorm with Aston demonstration at IBC 2013

  • Brainstorm at IBC 2013

    Brainstorm at IBC 2013

  • Featured Clip: Geoff Boyle comments on NAB 2012

    Featured Clip: Geoff Boyle comments on NAB 2012

  • Brainstorm at NAB 2012

    Brainstorm at NAB 2012

  • VIZRT at BVE 2012

    VIZRT at BVE 2012

  • Newtek at BVE 2012

    Newtek at BVE 2012

  • Sony at ProVideo2011

    Sony at ProVideo2011

  • Sisvel Technology at IBC2011

    Sisvel Technology at IBC2011

  • Sensio at IBC2011

    Sensio at IBC2011

  • Panasonic at IBC2011

    Panasonic at IBC2011

  • Doremi at IBC2011

    Doremi at IBC2011

  • Matrox at IBC2011

    Matrox at IBC2011

  • Blackmagic at IBC2011

    Blackmagic at IBC2011

  • SGO at IBC2011

    SGO at IBC2011

  • Marshall Electronics at IBC2011

    Marshall Electronics at IBC2011


Related Shows
  • Show 20 - July 17th 2013

    Show 20 - July 17th 2013


Articles
Review: JVC GY-HC900 Camera
Andy McKenzie JVC has a long history of developing relatively low price-point equipment, dating right back to its success in the 1970s with the VHS tape format. JVC products sometimes impact the broadcast mainstream but generally find greatest success in niche market segments such as news production where price and portability take priority over the no-comprise quality and robustness demanded by the leading studio-based and OB content producers.
Tags: iss138 | jvc review | camera | sdhc | sdxc | mpeg-2 | nab | gy-hc900 | Andy McKenzie
Contributing Author Andy McKenzie Click to read or download PDF
How the Womens World Cup was Boosted by Broadcast
John Griffiths As we write this article, England’s Lionesses have just beaten Norway 3-0 and are smashing viewing figure records, with 6.9 million viewers tuning in to watch them play Cameroon on BBC One. Rewind to the previous World Cup in 2015, and England’s group and early stage knockout games tempted up to 2.5 million viewers for each match. It’s safe to say that women’s football is finally having its moment; what was perhaps once considered a niche sport is finally gaining momentum in the mainstream space with broadcasters giving it the attention it deserves.
Tags: iss138 | wwc | world cup | spicymango | diversity | John Griffiths
Contributing Author John Griffiths Click to read or download PDF
Making the Workflow Flow
Bruce Devlin - new The toughest things about being the Standards Vice President (SVP) is that everyone expects standards to be the most important thing. In all the systems that I’ve designed and deployed over the years, I've yet to find any production workflow that is 100% standards based. True, the core technologies may well be standards based, but the overall workflow is made up of many technology pieces from open source code, through de-facto delivery specifications based upon SMPTE or Trade Association Specifications that in turn depend on full, International Standards to work. I can already hear some folks saying "In the good old days, everything used standards", but I beg to disagree.
Tags: iss138 | pye museum | pye-philips | smpte | ietf | ieee | w3c | aes | Bruce Devlin - new
Contributing Author Bruce Devlin - new Click to read or download PDF
TVFutures. No More Comfort Zone - Get a Placement
Michelle Brown I have often heard that any chance of getting work in the television industry is based quite heavily on who you know, and whilst that might indeed be true, I’ve also come to the realisation that it may also depends on what opportunities you seize and how far out of your comfort zone you might be prepared to push yourself.
Tags: iss138 | portsmouth uni | creative careers | placement | Michelle Brown
Contributing Author Michelle Brown Click to read or download PDF
State of the Nation: Wings, Fine Coffee and Fake Nudes
Dick Hobbs - new One of the many attractions of this time of year is that I get to meet with my fellow judges for the IBC Innovation Awards, and see what the industry sees as the most important, most forward-looking projects of the day. For me, this says what the key talking points are going to be in September, far more eloquently than the endless press releases from vendors which are already tumbling into my inbox.
Tags: iss138 | ibc | smpte 2110 | deepnude | cisco | Dick Hobbs - new
Contributing Author Dick Hobbs - new Click to read or download PDF